Technical Workflow: Pull Request Review#

Review a PR in GitHub. AI may review alongside a human, but the human reviewer checks the change independently and makes the approval decision. The shared rules apply.

Before You Start#

The author has checked the changes as described in Technical Workflow: Pull Request Authoring. The PR explains the change and links to the issue or change request. The reviewers have access to the relevant documents, templates, and checklists.

Parallel human and AI review with a final human approval decision

Fig. 28 Human and AI reviews run in parallel. The human reviewer checks the change and the review comments before approving or requesting changes.#

Steps#

  1. Request reviewers. The author requests the required human reviewers, including applicable codeowners. The reviewer must be someone other than the author. If AI review is used, request Copilot or another permitted tool to review the same version of the PR.

  2. Review in parallel. The human reviewer checks the change against the source material and applicable criteria, without waiting for AI results. AI provides additional comments. No AI findings does not mean the change is correct; human review still covers the full change.

  3. Address comments. The author answers the human and AI comments, makes corrections, or explains why a suggestion should not be applied. The human reviewer checks the answers and changes.

  4. Review corrections. After new commits, the author reruns affected checks and requests human re-review. Repeat AI review if needed, or make clear that its earlier review does not cover the new changes.

  5. Approve or request changes. The human reviewer records the decision in GitHub. Blocking issues must be resolved before approval. An AI response or passing automated checks cannot replace human sign-off.

The PR can be merged under existing repository rules once all required human approvals and checks are complete for the final changes. If further changes are made, they need review too. GitHub keeps the commits, comments, checks, and approvals; this workflow does not require a separate review report.